Monday, October 27, 2008

Yo, John McCain, while you’re in Pennsylvania...

WE'VE MOVED! Democratic Convention Watch is now at http://www.DemocraticConventionWatch.com

This is not an editorial, but it is an opinion piece in the Philadelphia Daily News. It captures not only a number of things people don't often bring up about the urban vs. rural culture wars, but it truly has a Philly tone. It's reprinted in its entirety, including the title.

CANDIDATE McCain: We've been bothered by your support of and strategy for the Iraq war, but we're more troubled by your support for the domestic war your campaign has declared. That would be the culture war between small towns and big cities.

If you're hoping to win Pennsylvania, or at least this part of it, you should call for a cease-fire. For one thing, this isn't a war you can win. Not with 80 percent of the country's population living in metropolitan areas.

At the Republican convention and at rallies around the country, your running mate has been vocal about this division. She recently said: "We believe that the best of America is in these small towns that we get to visit, and in these wonderful little pockets of what I call the real America, being here with all of you hardworking, very patriotic, very pro-America areas of this great nation. This is where we find the kindness and the goodness and the courage of everyday Americans..."


It's easy to romanticize small towns, especially if you watch Turner Classic Movies. We can imagine the idea of a slower pace, a place where Andy Griffith greets Donna Reed each morning at the pie shop, where men join the volunteer fire department and the social highlight is going to the library.

Senator, you like to insist when you're bashing your opponent that you're just speaking the facts. So here are some facts:

Methamphetamine use, one of the country's top drug problems, is more prevalent among rural youth; according to research from the Rural Health Research & Policy Centers, youth adults in small rural areas use meth twice as much as their urban counterparts.

Rural America's youth have a serious substance-abuse problem when it comes to alcohol, too.


The highest birth rates among the unwed are in two states that have high rural populations, Mississippi and New Mexico.


Rural populations show a higher incidence of heart disease, respiratory disease, disability associated with chronic health conditions, and obesity.


Researchers are also concerned that child obesity is rising faster in rural communities in several states, including Pennsylvania, New Mexico, Michigan, West Virginia, and North Carolina.


Of course, cities have problems, too. But it's clear we contribute far more to the economy than our rural neighbors. According to the Brookings Institution, the top 100 metropolitan areas are home to 68 percent of America's jobs and the origin of 75 percent of the nation's gross domestic product. Cities are less dependent on foreign oil, too, since so many of us take mass transit, or even walk to work. As for patriotism, well, guess where the Liberty Bell, Independence Hall, and the Constitution Center live?


And that reminds us: Among the Founding Fathers, Thomas Jefferson was famously not a big-city guy. But Ben Franklin — who, by the way, invented the library, and established the first volunteer fire department among other innovations — was a Philly guy, and he was also at home in London and Paris.
He also said that we must all hang together, or most assuredly, we shall all hang separately.

Think about that next time you dis our cities.

Comments (7)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
Login or signup now to comment.
I see nothing of fomenting a culture war in what Sarah Palin said. It does take some courage to live in a small town. You take a hit economically in a way. Yes its cheaper but there are less opportunities. But it can be a better place to raise a family. I see this post as trying to fabricate negativity in what the Republicans are saying.
Reply
3 replies · active less than 1 minute ago
Karen Anne's avatar

Karen Anne · 859 weeks ago

Small towns and rural areas also tend to have poor health care, due to the shortage of doctors and the distance to get to them.

Calling some areas of the country "pro-American" and others not is fomenting something, not what I hope to see in a potential national leader. But then again that's from the party whose Rev. Hagee thinks New Orleans deserved Katrina.
Reply
Hagee! Ha! And the Democrats don't have anybody like that in their party. Let me see...Sharpton, Farrakhan, Alec Baldwin. Lots of normalcy there.
Reply
As soon as you listed Farrakhan as a "Democrat" you lost ALL credibility as a Thinking Commentator ...
Reply
I think the point is that those in glass houses.....Farrakhan or not, there are some nuts in the Democratic party.
Reply
Those of us in small towns know the difficulty we face in getting young professionals over-burdened by student loans to locate to our communities. We also face the problem of upgrading aged water systems and aged sewer systems in areas without a large tax base.

Cutting aid for higher education and cutting assistance to local governments as proposed by the Republicans does not help small town America. Of course, the Republicans hope that if they wave the flag enough and emphasize the culture wars, they will keep us distracted long enough to hide their slight of hand.
Reply
uplandpoet's avatar

uplandpoet · 859 weeks ago

i love small towns, and big cities! I love america, and the world! not sure why the GOP feel the need to say if you love america you must hate paris and BA, and if you love Earle Arkansas, you must hate New Orleans. Small towns support big cities, and big cities support small towns, and I am very glad we have a party and soon to be elected president who isnt interested in trashing one group to endear itself with another. you kn ow the flamingest gay couple and the most conservative home schooled bible thumpers both want the same things: a safe place to work, raise a family and to not have the government in their bedrooms, a decent education and decent job for themselves and their children. TOGETHER we can create the change we need! sounds good! who says that? oh yeah, the skinny black guy from chicago, GO OBAMA!!!!!!
Reply

Comments by