Wednesday, June 11, 2008

General Election Tracker - June 11

WE'VE MOVED! Democratic Convention Watch is now at http://www.DemocraticConventionWatch.com

This is the DemConWatch General Election Tracker, a summary of the best election projections on the web.

We will be introducing House and Senate trackers later this month.

Update 6/11: Updated OpenLeft, Frontloading and Electoral-Vote.com

Obama Average: 275.2 (was 277.8), due in large part to 3 projections moving South Carolina from Tossup to McCain-Lean, which was due to a new Rasmussen Poll showing McCain with a 48-39 lead. As we expected, the tossups didn't hold.Which removes South Carolina from the list of states spanning 3 categories. We still have:

Connecticut: Electoral-vote.com has it as a toss-up - that won't last.

Florida: NBC and CNN have it as a tossup, but Electoral-vote.com has it as Strong McCain. Expect everybody to move to McCain-Lean for now.

Indiana: Three have it as a toss-up, but NPR has it as Strong McCain. If Obama can keep this state in McCain-Lean, that's a good sign in a state that Kerry lost by 21%.

New Mexico: OpenLeft has it as Obama-Lean, CNN at McCain-Lean

North Dakota - Two have it as tossup - that won't last.

Map showing consensus of sources. Wisconsin moves from Obama to Tossup, as the last Obama-Lean ranking goes away. (But late update: A new poll just came out giving Obama a 13 point lead - expect WI to move quickly to Obama-Lean across the board).

<p><strong>><a href='http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/politics/interactives/campaign08/electoral-college/'>Electoral College Prediction Map</a></strong> - Predict the winner of the general election. Use the map to experiment with winning combinations of states. Save your prediction and send it to friends.</p>


Consensus solid states:
Obama: CA, DC, HI, IL, MD, NY, RI, VT - 131 EVs.
McCain: AL, AZ, ID, KS, OK, TX, UT, WY - 78 EVs
(June11: TX added to McCain consensus solid states due to EV.com moving from ML to M.

The sources are now sorted by their Obama Estimate. The states are sorted by number of electoral votes.

DCW General Election Tracker
State
EVsOpenLeftElectoral-
Vote.com
NBCCNN538.comFront LoadedNPR....
Date

6/106/116/56/96/76/116/9
Obama (O)

185175153153178142143
Obama-Lean (OL)

57594737506557
Tossup (T)

899413815494129111
McCain-Lean (ML)

615784697856110
McCain (M)

146153116125138146117
Obama Total

242234200190228207200
McCain Total

207210200194216202227
Obama Est

287.3280.6276.4273.4273.1269.7266.1

Florida
27MLMTTMLMLML
Pennsylvania
21OLOLTTOLTT
Ohio
20TTTTTTT
Michigan
17TTTTTTT
Georgia
15MMMLMLMMML
New Jersey
15OOLOLOLOLOLOL
N. Carolina
15MLMLMLMLMLMLML
Virginia
13TTTTTTT
Massachusetts
12OLOOOOOLO
Indiana
11TTMLMLMLTM
Missouri
11TTMLTTTML
Tennessee
11MMMMMMML
Washington
11OOOLOLOOLOL
Minnesota
10OOOLTOOLOL
Wisconsin
10TTTTTTT
Colorado
9OLOLTTTTT
Louisiana
9MMLMLMLMMML
Kentucky
8MMMMMMML
S. Carolina
8MLMLMMMLMLM
Conn.
7OTOOOLOOL
Iowa
7OLOLTTOLOLT
Oregon
7OOOLOLOOLOL
Arkansas
6MMMLMLMMML
Mississippi
6MMLMLMMMM
Nebraska
5MMMLMMMM
Nevada
5MLMLTTTTT
New Mexico
5OLTTMLTTT
W. Virginia
5MMLMMLMLMML
Maine
4OOOLOLOOOL
NH
4TOLTTTTT
Alaska
3MLMLMMMLMLM
Delaware
3OLOLOOOOLOL
Montana
3MLMLMLMLMLMLML
N. Dakota
3TMLMLMMLTM
S. Dakota
3MMMMMLMM






























































Notes:
We're purposely ignoring Maine and Nebraska CD splits for now to keep things simple. We'll add them in later if we need to.

The Obama estimate gives Obama 100% of the EVs in a state that is solid for them, 80% of the EVs for a leaner, 50% of the EVs for a Tossup, and 20% of the EVs for state that is McCain-Lean.

538.com state projections determined from state winning percentage (>90%: Strong, 65-90%: Lean, 50-65%: Tossup). Overall number based on 538.com simulation.

Comments (14)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
Login or signup now to comment.
Please don't forget to link the new tracker to the left top page link. I am still hoping that ya'll will add RCP to the tracker ;)
Reply
This new commenting procedure is confusing. Maybe ya'll could post a thread explaining the new program - login why? and what is Claim my comments ? - and how to add a photo if possible. I don't like the new text box ;(
Reply
How do you delete your own post?
Reply
Oh my god! First you take away our other commenting procedure now you are trying to blind us! Are ya'll going to put some blue and red in the top part too for Obama and McCain so it will be easier to read? I still can't figure out how to 'login'.
Reply
I just wanted to point something out about electoral-vote.com. They aren't really making projections. They go exclusively off the latest polling data. So the only reason Florida is Strong McCain is because the lastest poll has him up 10+. The only reason Connecticut is barely Obama is because polling data has it close. So if tomorrow a poll comes out that McCain is only 2 points ahead of Obama in Utah then the map would show it barely McCain...

My point is... saying electoral-vote has this state barely democrat and it should be strong democrat really isn't being fare to the site its all methodology and not actual analysis.
Reply
antigravity's avatar

antigravity · 874 weeks ago

James -

aren't all these sites just using polling data to make projections? what other analysis do they do? (i am genuinely not familiar with some of these..)

i know each site/blogger chooses which polls to use (which pollsters, how recent, etc.) differently. E-V.com in fact averages the polls taken within the last week: http://www.electoral-vote.com/evp2008/Info/pollin...(scroll to the bottom), which is an analytical choice that is used in part because of the relative success in tracking the 2004 election....

i agree though - either way we can't simply consider these as equally footed opinions...
Reply
Some do and some don't. The major media outlets use a combination of history and recent polling data. Thats the whole reason we have differences. If it was based off pure polling data they would all be the same.
Reply
great page! the great variety of blogs, analysis and polls (+ vivid discussions around it) is something that makes US elections really interesting to europeans like myself!
Reply
just to add...

1) including RCP would definitely be interesting

2) do you consider your pollsters leaning to one side? it's quite typical at least in austria that pollsters are known to lean a bit towards one of the large parties... would be interesting to get some insight
Reply
If you take the current consensus map and make just one change - move Iowa over to McCain - and then divide the "undecided" states as follows: NM, WI and OH to Obama, VA and MI to McCain, you get a very interesting EV total...
Reply
I'm not sure that I agree with your methodology for determining "consensus" -- everyone with the exception of electoral-vote.com has New Hampshire as a tossup -- I'm not sure that makes the consensus that it is a blue state. I'd think the consensus is that New Hampshire is a tossup.
Reply
Great page, but I would like the link to the left to point to the last version of the tracker, so I can put that link in my favourites...
Reply
Historical analysis is useful until things change. Which means that it's a good way to miss change. A couple of the sites in the list use polling data exclusively but they have different methodology for the weights that they give polls.

Michael, we do have some polling companies that have historically tilted slightly one (mostly based on their assumptions about likely voters) way or the other. In addition, we do have polling companies that actually work for candidates. The different sites take those factors into account in determining how much weight to give each poll.
Reply

Comments by